What would be the best way to solve The problem of Illegal Immigration?
Answer:
Punish those who employ them. No job=no money and no way to survive. I mean I really really to understand how crappy it is where they live BUT we have our own problems too. They keep coming because they KNOW they can get jobs!
Oooo and I just thought they should also go after those who rent housing to illegals. No ssn = no apartment.
I think that is probably the most effective means.
The fence idea is just stupid. I'm sorry but the cost and the maintenance and upkeep and staffing..jeesh that's like what my child would have come up with.
As far as enforcing existing laws, as much as that should be done, there is simply not the funds or manpower to round up illegal immigrants already here and ship them back.
I have nothing against immigrants period. In fact I feel really bad that most of them were born where they were. But we still have homeless Americans and children who aren't getting healthcare and enough to eat. Senior who can't afford medicine. Single parents who can't afford daycare. Americans need to fix our own problems as well.
The problem with illegal immigration can be solved the same way we solve our problem with illegal drugs: make them legal.
Yeah, all we really need to do is enforce our existing laws and follow through with plans of action. This isn't being done though. We need to remove the people from office who have a responsibility to uphold the law yet neglect this duty.
i would invite as many hard working latinos as i could find. they are replacing our welfare-sponging low life population, doing the work that the others won't, 10x better and faster. personally i like industrious, family-oriented, religious people. who better to learn and spread the message of freedom and democracy. but that's just me, maybe america is fine just the way it is.
well you sound like someone the wall should keep out
I think our government intentionally let it happen. Think about it. The only grounds to be against illegals is that they are lawbreakers. But they are breaking laws so they can peacefully enter the workforce... They aren't endangering the population in this capacity. Since it's not the first time they just want to legalize them and move on, I think it's reasonable to conclude that they have no intentions of sealing off the border properly.
I say pass this bill granting amnesty, but really secure the border this time. At the same time, provide an easier path to a working license or citizenship for anyone that wants to come over here.
I suggest that we make all of the illegal immigrants in this country, legal citizens of the United States. This way, they will have to pay taxes and earn their right to live in our country. Enough said.
There is no solution now. We should have fix it back in the day...but now we have immigrants in political power. We made laws that gave them an 'in'...such as, "if your born here your American" even if your parents are illegal.
Fixing immigration would be as hard as getting rid of ants.
Enforcement of our laws, and control of our borders and ports. It's just that easy.
The only means to control this issue is to impose onerous fines and prison terms to those that would employ illegal immigrants. You cut off the jobs and there is absolutely no reason to come to this country illegally. A few CEO's in jail and the others will behave... They are greedy, not stupid.
~
Build a Berlin Wall between Mexico and the USA, with the goal of keeping people out, instead of keeping them in.
Several obstacles, including a big re-inforced concrete wall, barbed wire, patrols, obstacles to stop vehicles from going through, tear gas boobytraps, whatever. Build it along the entire border.
Well, I think the answer to this question is mostly an opinion. Some people do not believe that illegal immigration is a problem. They think that illegal immigrants should be allowed. So I think there is not an absolute answer to this question.
First step of knocking down that bill happened today!
I would propose making employers of illegals step forward rather than illegals themselves, or in addition to illegals. Agree not to penalize them (employers) as long as within 5 years, they send all of their illegal employees back home and replace them with legals. This would avoid economic shock. After these 5 years or if you don't step forward and are found out, you suffer extremely high penalties fine and jail time. Same for illegals that don't step forward... only they get deported... permanently.
Making something illegal doesn't make something go away. We need to make it less profitable for illegal immigrants to come here and less profitable for employers to hire illegals. We also need to increase the likelihood of getting caught either entering the country illegally or hiring illegal immigrants. Easier said than done, I am afraid.
Annex mexico, make it the 51st state.
Frees up a ton of resources for the rest of our borders.
Increase legal immigration quotas. We could use more good workers and good neighbors. The illegal immigrants might decide to go back and come in legally.
I would for instance, hold countries like Mexico responsible and make them cough up the $33 billion illegals cost the United States tax payers every year. It would also be good to hold countries such as, Mexico responsible for withholding millions of dollars from its people who come to America for a better way of life illegally.
Point given, if a country such as, Mexico can fund these Hispanic organizations to mobilize illegal immigration protests in the United States and keep a large cash surplus in its pockets then it has enough money to spread around to help its poor.
Nobody deserves a free ride. Especially these animals marching upon our capitol steps thinking they deserve rights.
I think there is two equally effective ways to solve the problem. Announce that all illegal immigrants are to be shot if caught and carry out this punishment 100% of the time. Machine gun towers on the border would prevent an invasion of more immigrants. The other way is to make the illegals legal and allow them to stay and work under certain guidelines that would be made. I think the second option is better but the first might reflect 21st century America more accurately.
I think that, sadly, the only sure-fire way that we could solve this problem is to send them all back to their countries and put up walls around our country that are constantly and fully guarded.and if people are caught in our country, they will be killed. They must apply legally to come to our country.
But its a cruel way of handling things, and doesnt provide much compromise. There would be riots on the streets and lots of turmoil, but after that, we wouldnt have as much of a problem with coming to this country illegally.
Dual citizenship?
I heard Kennedy say this morning that ...'I've heard what they don't want (referring to the US citizens), but they won't tell us what they want."
I don't know how much clearer we can make it.. We don't want 12 millions new citizens with the stroke of a pen. They are illegals and need to be deal with as criminals. Why should they be rewarded for breaking the law? It would just promote more influx of illegals waiting for the next amnest bill to pass.
The way to solve the problem... is to take care of the border and then ENFORCE our already in place immigration laws. Go after the illegals and those that employee them.
The problem would go away pretty quickly.
If you get caught with an illegal, you lose 1/3 of your money and 1/3 of your income for the next year. all that money goes to border enforcement.
first, vote republicans out of office. they will do anything to support big business. this last bill would have been bad for everybody, including the Illegals. the only one that would have benefited was big business. they get a lot of cheap labor so they can fire the citizens who have been there too long and make too much.
second, move prisons and military base to all of our borders, they can do double duty of patrolling the borders.
finally, and most importantly, deport Illegal Immigrants.
The problem is: it's too big. How can you possible crack down 12 millions people in this country. Even if they did crack down on some of their employers and I say some. How in the world will the goverment find the time and money to do that. They should of given them amnesty but even with that, the problem will never be fix. The goverment has too many things to deal with. I heard from a friend of mine who's a lawyer for immigration, that once the immigration has decided to deport you, if you don't show up on the date they have given you, they dont care and they don't go after you...So why waste time and money to make them go through all of that. Everybody's talking about a SSN , do you know that all they have to pay is $200 and they get a fake one. And the goverment can't detect it either...
So the bottom line is, they waited to long , they don't know what to do about it and they don't really care.
If illegals want to work in the U.S they get a visit by teamsters and be forced to accept higher pay, and not work as scab undercutting laborers.
The Immigration information post by website user , MyTend.com not guarantee correctness.
More Immigration Questions and Answers ...