Is this a sell-out of our American birthright, or is it a good deal for all concerned?

According to CBS News correspondent Sharyl Attkisson, the group, which includes Democratic Sen. Ted Kennedy and Republican Sen. Lindsey Graham, has met for hours several times a week since March — with Homeland Security chief Michael Chertoff acting as point man for the White House.

CBS News has been told the plan that could be announced next week attempts to please hardliners by spending billions to secure the border first. But all 12 million-plus illegal immigrants could stay. They'd have to register and pay fines for having entered illegally.

To become citizens, they'd go to the end of the line behind those who've already applied.

Under a new merit plan, points would be given for work skills and language: The more points, the faster they can become citizens.

And everyone — even U.S. citizens — would have to prove who they are when applying for a job.

The bottom line: An illegal immigrant here today could remain in the U.S., but would wait 13 years for citizenship.

Answer:
Works for me.

I wonder how many people on this board can even comprehend how impossible it would be to round up 12 million people and ship them back to Mexico. It would be an act on par with the Nazi "final solution" in terms of how many people it would displace.

America is a nation of immigrants, you need to understand that those here now will not just up and leave if we tell them, and we cannot just round them up and ship them out. It doesn't work that way.

Be realistic, amnesty and tighter border controls are what we need to do, not draconian "throw them all out" measures, which, quite frankly, would be impossible to pull off.
sell out. They don't really want citizenship anyway.they just want to plunder our social services and make money to send back to mexico.
Anything Ted Kennedy is pushing should be bagged and tossed into a dumpser.

The illegals WOULD NOT register, they WOULD NOT pay any fines, and why should they? Just so they can keep on doing what they are doing now for free?

Ted Kennedy should have stayed down there with Mary Jo Kopechne and spared us all his gibberish.
Jeez- I'd stop watching CBS.
Sell out. Here's an idea-if they are here ILLEGALLY send them home. Every illegal immigrant (NOT undocumented worker) is a criminal.
I dont trust the government to secure the border before doing anything like this. Their track record sucks.If its not secured then it will be just like the last amnesty. The rush to get over here would begin for millions more of the illegals, I dont see why they deserve any damn thing they need to be deported back to the S*** hole they came from.
Logically this makes no kinna sense. Why not just give all criminals amnesty.pen the prison doors. No amnesty and send em home.
F*** A its a sell out.
Kennedy has a Catholic agenda. He only wants Catholic immigrants.

He is still mad that Americans almost didn't elect his brother to be president because he was Catholic.

It is easy to round them up and deport them. Just deputized honest unemployed Americans to help with the deportations.

Set up detention camps near rail road tracks. Then load the criminals on trains and drop them off at the Mexican border.

An Arizona sherrif has has a lot of success with hiring citizens to round up illegal aliens.
I was an illegal for 14 years and I became successful I am now a nurse. I never asked for welfare the only ppl I've seenask fo welfare and beg for money in the streets are americans.never in my life have I seen a mexican beg for money in a street corner.
Illegal aliens have become the most hated people in America.
There is no other race, religion, or minority that is acceptable to publicly hate.
Illegal aliens are being blamed for underfunded hospitals, schools, crime, drugs, disease, terrorism, and every other problem in America.
Why do you people need someone to blame for everything!
Hitler had the Jews to blame, America has the illegal aliens.

To suggest that we arrest and imprison 12 million, cleaning ladies, gardeners, baby sitters, maids, laborers and other hard working people is ridiculous. Do you really want to pay twice as much to eat in a restaurant? Would you like to clean your own hotel room and do the laundry?

Rich capitalists are not the only ones who benefit from these inexpensive foreign workers - you do!

Don't be a hater! Illegal aliens are not responsible for all of America's problem and neither are any other minority. It should be just as unacceptable to express prejudice for Illegal immigrants as it is for any other group.

The medicine information post by website user , MyTend.com not guarantee correctness.

  • Do I have to get my passport renewed now that I am married?
  • Why should we differentiate between "civil and criminal" illegal aliens? Aren't they all the same (illegal)?
  • Do you think Americans should sue the federal government for crimes committed by illegal aliens?
  • Why do illegals come to the USA? Is it for slave wages that they are paid?
  • With the new immigration plan...?
  • Married an illegal alien...possibly not legally married..do I need a divorce or anullment?
  • Question about the immigration bill and LEGAL immigrants?
  • While the immigration bill takes all of the headlines, what is Congress up to on the trade front?
  • I want to move to canada!!! HOW DO I DO THIS (from usa)?
  • Is THIS their 'family values'?