Deport them all ?
Does anyone out there ACTUALLY want that? In this day and age in this country of freedom and equality? Speak up if you do.
Answer:
For many, the slogan seems to be 'WWAD"
What would Adolf do?
We forget that all of us are visitors to these shores and displaced the Native Americans 515 years ago.
For too many, it's the land of the free (but only for those like us).
They cannot articulate a practical plan to implement their ideas. Those who support deportation are not guided by reason, but emotional rage. This explains why they support something that cannot be practically achieved.
theyre not thinking with their heads, only with hate...dont try to rationalize with them
Can't we just fly them all to Venezuela and let them be Hugo Chavez's problem? Or what about Cuba? I hear that they have wonderful health care there.
Oh, I am positive there are people who could do all that and sleep very well at night too. U.S. citizens beat, rob, rape, attack and kill other U.S. citizens every day! Why would they object to doing it to illegal immigrants?
The simple fact is that logistically, it can't be done.
they r illegal they r bad
they should all go back home
look how many ppl illegals rape and kill
u think we should pay for them to go to school and health care cuz they knew how to get into the country and milk da system nooooo
You're right, mass deportation wouldn't work but we can make it very hard for them to be here. They would have to leave on their own. When they start returning to their own countries in masses, maybe THEIR governments will start coming up with proactive solutions.
They will only resort to insults and not give you an intelligent, thoughtful answer, because they have none!
President Eisenhower had great success on deporting Illegal Aliens in the 1950's with his "Operation ...back."
Can be done again even on a larger scale.
The logistics of this works by securing the border, penalizing employers, empowering local law enforcement nation wide to be able to inquire as to someones legal status when stopped for infractions. Establishing an INS system of pick up and drop off (Buses). The rest will be taken care of by attrition. Lets say we have 20 million illegals here today, 20 years from now its not unrealistic if the above things happen, to get that number down into single digits, there ya have it Honey, that's how its done.
PS, Yes I want this, along with 80% of the rest of America, we want the border secured and illegals to lose all incentives to stay here.
I know they are trying to make a living, but I HATE when they come into MY country where I was born and raised and try to get rights that they don't have because they are NOT citizens. They barge in here illegally and get mad when they aren't treated like a god or goddess. I know not all of them are. I don't think it is realistic for them all to be deported, but if it was possible I would say yes. Wait your turn. There are plenty of people waiting a LONG time and coming in legally. They can do the same.
No...there is no way you can round up 12 million people. That's just silly and simple-minded people talking out of their butts all the time.
And big business wants them here, so they're not going anywhere.
If this is a question about aliens in US, then The United States of America was founded by aliens from Europe, who came after Christoper Columbus discovered America, killing and driving the aborigines, Red Indians ,away and robbing their lands.
Now the same people shout at the top of their voice about Mexicans, Arabs, Indians and Pakistanis etc coming and taking jobs in USA.
How funny this looks!
we can't just deport them all because many of these people came here in search of the same things that the founding fathers of America came for. It would be wrong for us to just reject them and send them back to their harsh lives before they came to this country.
First, we need to repeal baby anchor laws, as most nations have already done. Allow the parents to take their babies with them. At adulthood, they can return or earlier if their parents apply for legal status and receive permission to re-enter and live in the US.
Logistically, it would take time.
But a joint effort of federal, state, and local authorities, augmented with National Guard would work, provided the borders were adequately secured first. Prior to deportation, each individual would need to be given the opportunity to prove status as a citizen or legal immigrant. Documents should be verified that they are not stolen or fake.
Eliminating the inducements to be here illegally should be concurrent with detainment and deportation efforts.
Cut off all forms of financial aid and jobs. Eliminate free health care, with the exception of life-threatening situations, and free education. Many would self-deport.
For a nation to remain free and equal, honoring the law is paramount. Legal immigrants honor our laws. Illegal aliens did not. There should not be any rewards for law-breaking.
There is a legal path to the US. They should have taken it, but since they didn't, they merit the path out.
I do - even if you and they don't.
many illegal immigrant advocates say "breaking up families".
Hmmm- here's a solution - they can ALL go back together.
Wherever they're from.
Take their Anchor Babies, go back home, get in line, and OBEY THE LAW.
Why should we reward CRIMINALS?
I have MANY friends following the law, and patiently waiting in line.
Why should ILLEGAL Immigrants be given ANY leeway?
No need to break up familes- if mommy and daddy are illegal, they can take thier kids with them as they head out the door.
And, it wouldn't happen in the night, in boxcars as you inflammatorily charge. Who are you, Michael Moore?
It would be an orderly, systematic, staggered deportation, with mandatory time out of the country.
Perhaps their home countries (that they LOVE so much) will come up with a solution to keep them there, and fix their economies.
Get em all out Spanky and like now! Good Day !
Yes. No one is to blame for separating a family but the illegal parents. The law was there clearly, that said if you sneak into this country and have a anchor babies that you will be responsible to take that child with you if you are deported. End of story. No seperation here.
They have no right to have a child in this country anyway.
The freebie nipple will be turned off , jobs will be imposible to get without proper documents and most will self deport.
It is sad that people (anti-illegals) seem to ignorantly avoid the fact that 12 million illegal immigrants will not be deported. It has been said several times, and quite frankly, it is getting pretty old and invalid, and just plain ignorant that people say we should deport all 12 million illegals. It is not going to happen, ever.
I just don't know what to say anymore. I can only wish you anti-illegals the best in your sad lives.
There will be no mass deportation. "look at history. The illegals will mostly end up staying--and like every other immigrant group, assimilate and make good citizens. You won't be able to tell their kids from any other American kid."
We wouldn't be rounding them up in the middle of the night and separating families. All you have to do is say they they have 48 hrs to get out or turn them selves into proper authorities, then have American volunteers (which would be about 200,000,000 ) to do the rest, it could be done relatively cheap! The only people who deserve freedom and equality in the United States are American citizens who respect this country, which most illegals ( 98%) don't.
"Go Down Moses! Set My People Free!"
That's the answer. Set them free to return to Mexico. Stop the welfare we've addicted them to. Re-open Plyler v. Doe and demand that the court respect the intentions (well-recorded in the 39th Congressional Globe) of all who voted to ratify it.
That will end birth-right citizenship and $27,000/family/year that Legal American Citizens are paying in taxes to illegal invaders.
Respect that right of our citizens and all these 12 to 40 million will go home voluntarily.
They are "La Raza" - motto: For the Race [Superior], everything! For all others, nothing!" But when they have to pay for "everything", they'll prefer to go back where it's cheaper - home! Set these people free! Heal them of this addiction to free money!
qwerty
Sure, why not.
They could have come here legally. Maybe there is a wait of a few years, but people in the other parts of the world seem to be able to wait.
How do you deport them all? Tell local law enforcement to notify ICE every time they pull over an illegal or arrest one. If the department refuses, pull their Federal funding. Start enforcing employer sanctions. Lets see some fat cats screwing American workers by hiring these illegals do some perp walks. Tell ICE to get off their *** and start deporting people. Fund ICE to enable it to happen. Make life difficult for illegals and ignore the whining from bleeding hearts.
Yes, it can be done. But first take away the jobs, make it so they can't find jobs, next make it so they can't find a place to live, in the end, no jobs, no place to live, many will self deport.
Yes I DO want this. Do it in stages. In stages, it will show the illegals what happens to their families when they break the law and build their houses on sand instead of rock. If they see it actually happening, they will start to leave on their own. These things need to be in place before we start. #1 Build the wall and have every airport and seaport in range of mexico equipped with a "Port of Entry" set up. Call it Homeland Security, if you want. Whatever, just DO IT! This will require hiring a many thousands of INS agents. Apprehended illegals known to be criminals could be used as labor for building it. #2 Set up a "fast lane" trial for employers that hire illegals and the owners of such companies. Minimum jail times should be established, just like with "Three Strikes" offenders. Their businesses should be confiscated for a second offense. #3 Set up orphanages for anchor baby offspring of soon-to-be deported illegal immigrants. They may return to mexico to be reunited with their parents ONLY if they renounce their US citizenships. Parents may sign for those too young to do so for themselves. 18 would be the minimum age to opt to stay on your own. #4 Set up an infalable national ID card. Once all this is set up, start the sweeps. Pull up with a dozen busses to the local El Tigre market and lock the doors. Check their cards one at a time with a satellite-linked "base station" van. At the van, they are allowed ONE phone call. Those with no card go straight to the deportation busses. Those with faked papers are "double criminals" and go straight to the prison busses. Those with criminal records also go to the prison busses but are handcuffed to the seat. If there is anyone left in the store, bid them good day. Call the tow trucks to have the vehicles of the apprehended taken to the addresses specified by the owners or perhaps the auction yard (to pay for the fines for crossing illegally.) Do this ONCE and make it STICK and they will start leaving on their own.
I do,
illegal immigration is a crime, illegally obtaining welfare is
crime (fraud), not paying taxes is a crime. I personally
don't care how they are rounded up and don't care
if is the middle of the night or middle of the day.
Take the babies and wives with them, if the illegal is
married to an American citizen, he is no longer illegal
now, is he. Anchor babies do not count, you can not
be committing a crime and then create something that
is legal.
Yes, I do feel that way deep in my soul, now if all 12 million
are here legally, I don't have a problem with that, I might
even help them move their stuff up here.
I know we cannot deport them all. What they need to do is to stop employing illegals,stop giving them benefits that where intended for Americans and stop feeding them on our tax dollars. If they would stop all the free programs and they can't get jobs here they will stop coming. If you live anywhere next to the border you will have noticed the amount of crime caused by illegals. It is so easy to come here and when they do something bad they run back to Mexico, wait awhile and come back when the heat is off. I kid you not, we have to do something.
The Immigration information post by website user , MyTend.com not guarantee correctness.
More Immigration Questions and Answers ...