23 million est Iraq Population... 12-20 million Illegal Immigrants in the US.. Time to end at least one war?

I am a US citizen, pretty conservative. What benefit do Americans have of allowing illegals to reside and benefit from healthcare to unpaid income taxes? Also there is a security problem with allowing them to stay as illegals? Why would it be so bad to encourage/require the estimated 12.5-20M illegals to register (or ban perm... not just the 10 year ban they recieve now), allow them to pay their fines (5K+,financing available) for their illegal crossing, start taxing them on income and have them start paying for healthcare? 12.5-20 million times five thousand dollars in fines, times income taxes minus what we are currently spending to support them in our system should be a big plus. INS and the Gov. can focus on the non-registered, less overwhelmed. Use the surplus money to secure borders; not our taxes.My wife is illegal; almost impossible to legalize.. with my US baby. Let me pay her fines and move on. This is a battle the US can win! Note: We are financially sound.. no drain to US

Answer:
In the short term maybe.
However,
1. Illegals use illegal (stolen or forged documents) to gain employment so the taxes paid in wouldn't change.
2. In the long term, those that work here for a few years will ultimately be able to collect social security and without having paid in all of their lives, that system will be bankrupt much faster than it will be now.
3. This is amnesty. Anyone that crosses the border more than once is committing a felony. The amnesty as proposed wipes the slate clean even for those illegals that are gangbangers. I don't know about you, but I don't want amnesty for members of MS-13 and the other gangs, much less a bunch of unconvicted felons.
4. The government has to perform a background check within 24 hours of the applicant filing papers. But who are they checking? The real person, or someone that has completely forged their identity?
5. We don't reward criminals in this Country. We incarcerate them. If they are illegal, we then deport them.

Your solution looks good on the surface, but it has no depth to it.
If you haven't read this bill, please do so. It's long and it's a pain to read, but at the end of the day, it is worthless because it has no enforcement teeth in it. We have laws now that we aren't enforcing. That's all that has to happen. Enforce the laws currently on the books.
Why don´t you create a spanish-speaking country instead of Iraq ?

If Iraqis do not want to be part of anything involving the US, hispanics desperately want to be in the US...

So here is my plan:
Baghdad is renamed "El Bagdado del Rio"
All shi´ites temples are switched to catholic
Start growing corn and beans everywhere
Bravo!

I believe the Iraq population estimate is a little bit lower now!

You have to subtract 650,000 off that estimate since 2003
You say they don't pay income taxes. How do they get jobs then? The govt. requires employers to get identification including SS cards, drivers licenses, etc. from all applicants.

So if they are illegally working in the US, then they must have illegal documentation. Thus the employer still deducts taxes from their checks and sends the money to Uncle Sam.

Do you really think Uncle Sam turns down tax money (federal taxes, medicare, and social security) from an illegal social security card and gives it back to the employer?

Honestly?
MA-BY THEY WILL LET YOU TAKE CARE OF YOUR WIFE BUT THAT DOES NOT EXCUSE THE REST OF THEM. THEY ARE TAKING OUR JOBS,RAPING OUR WE MEN AND CHILDREN,AND KILLING PEOPLE LEFT AND RIGHT AND THEY CANT EVEN BE PROSECUTED FOR THERE CRIMES THEY ARE SENT BACK TO COME RIGHT BACK OVER HERE . YOU HAVE TAKEN ON THE RESPONSIBILITY OF YOUR WIFE SO FIGHT FOR HER BUT YOU CANT EXPECT THE REST OF US TO DO THAT.

The Immigration information post by website user , MyTend.com not guarantee correctness.


More Immigration Questions and Answers ...
  • Were white american, illegal immigrants once?
  • Well what will we do about illegals from all nationalities sneaking into america please read?
  • The United States of America 47 states?
  • Would i get a job easy in maastricht?
  • How to get British citizenship?
  • How do you feel about the Immigration reform?
  • Can anyone prove that the undocumeted depresse the wages of native Americans ? i heard that they do often?
  • Me and my wife just got married and she has a K-1 (fiance) visa. What do we have to do to get a green card now
  • The Immigration Bill just passed now what do you say?
  • If someone enters the US as an illegal alien, wouldn't that leave a permament mark of shame...?