Why should illegal immigrants receive amnesty??

Can anyone please give me a VALID reason?? Don't give me these lame excuses of how they are hard working and only want a better life for their families. Those stories do not fly!! Why should illegals be given SPECIAL TREATMENT?????

Millions of other immigrants came to the US because they are hard working and to get a better life! But unlike illegals, they actually became US Citizens!! What part of that don't illegals seem to understand??????????

Answer:
They should not. We must never reward law breakers, these people are openly and knowingly breaking our laws. Many have been deported up to 6 times, each time coming back. Also many have knowingly used stolen IDs and SS cards to get jobs and benefits. If we do give amnesty it would be a slap in the face to those who, payed the fees, did the paper work, and waited, sometimes for years, to do it the right way.
to heat up the great melting pot of the good old usa! diversification and the ultimate demise of the unwanted white european stock. whitey has had his day in the sun. it is the right thing to do. time to step aside for the downtrodden and weak.
Yeah as a legal still waiting to pay for paperwork and go the legal route to residency , i find it quite an insult for illegals to jump the queue.
Because I say so . Besides they are going to get amnesty. Legislation is already being passed. That should make you happy.
They shouldnt. They broke our laws.
Why should a turkey get Presidential Pardon on Thanksgiving? Gimmick in order to gather popularity with the masses. Our country is founded by immigranrs and aliens so therefore it is in keeping with our founding proclamation
There isn't any! They should not!! Problem is people aren't in the streets marching getting the attention of politicians!! Only the illegal march getting their attention!! What part don't government official understand!! They are trying to give illegals amnesty.
It is our fault. They should have been shot the minute they crossed the boarder.
Illegals should never be given amnesty!! I don't think our government really realizes the impact that these people have had on our country, they are destroying it. They don't deserve amesty!
So they can pay their taxes and add to the war coffer.
That is the bottom line in this amnesty thing. Income.
"Why should illegals be given SPECIAL TREATMENT?????"

Because their are 13 million of them in the U.S. and there's no way to get them out except by creating far worse problems than would be solved.

Amnesty, or the equivalent, is the only way to deal with the issue.
Doing it legally is too hard. People have no other choice but to come illegally.
They shouldn't and they won't.

My response to anyone saying "it is just SO hard for them to become legal" is that if it is too hard then stay in Mexico where life is easy. No demands to learn a new language or to support a country you hate and will never have loyalty to or become a real part of.

Moot point though as they will NEVER receive amnesty. The American people will not allow it and those who would have to enact the laws will be up for election in two years know the publics feelings and would rather have a job than support amnesty for criminals. DEPORT NOW!
Illegal ailens should be rounded up and sent home. I only want the legal ones here.
The United States is losing money. If you help immigrants then you help the economy generate more jobs. After 9/11 there has been a 20% drop in immigration to the U.S. because people didn't want to immigrate here. That 20% drop made the US lose billions of dollars. Might as well give the 12 million illegals that are here amnesty and a faster way to get their green cards. It will only help in the long run.
The answer is, so that they can vote for our worthless politicians. There is no other reason.

Dont be brainwashed by our politicians. Illegal aliens are ruining this country. Dont you know that it is both the Dems and Repubs that are working together to ruin this country? They are sucking the life out of us by giving this country away to corruption and immorality. The USA has had it, for greed, power and money designed and implemented by both camps. Dont be blind!!!

While you are at it, and while we still have this freedom, do some shopping at Amazon -

http://astore.amazon.com/desktopsupportt...
Because we're not going to deport 12 million people, especially when some of them have children born in the US and who are American citizens. If we're not going to deport them then the only we are going to know who they are is to give them an incentive to come forward. The only incentive that will work is the ability to apply for legal status, aka a green card.
It's in out national security interests to know who those people are.
They shouldn't and won't! Go go NumbersUSA and alipac.com and send those faxes off! Get on the Discussion Groups and let your voice be heard!

You can also recieve a REWARD if you go to irs.gov, download form 3949A, fill it out, make a copy send it off by Certified Mail. Each employer that hires illegals are fined $1,000.00. You will recieve 10% of what they find wrong!
Here's my answer, copied and pasted from another "amnesty" question that I answered:
There are a lot of pro-amnesty people who think that because these immigrants have come from an impoverished country/political instability/lack of job opportunities/poor living conditions, that we should have enough pity on them to grant them amnesty. Yes, it is very sad, the conditions these folks deal with in their home country. However....my great grandparents came here from Poland right after Hitler's forces bombed a church an killed several family members. They came here with the clothes on their back, and nothing more. They went through all the channels to become citizens legally, even though they had come from some horrible conditions back home. They even learned English. I'd like to know what has changed between then and now as far as what is considered poor enough living conditions to hand out amnesty.
There's no justifiable reason why they should be granted amnesty, but there are plenty of reasons why they shouldn't.

Yet, our leader, in his last (of too many) appearances is still pushing for that same worthless approach to the problem. Been there- done that! The last amnesty program was a failure, because here we are discussing the same old issue........

We need to control our borders. If Mexico was next to Saudi Arabia, instead of the U.S., do you believe that they would be as kind as we are to border violators??

ICE needs to be given a large set of teeth AND encouraged to bite with them. Nice doesn't work...............
I don't know reason, we must find them and send them home

The immigration information post by website user , MyTend.com not guarantee correctness

  • Should Christians be tolerant to Muslims living in the West or should they be deported back to their Muslim..?
  • Since 27% Of All U.S. Prisoners Are Foreigners, What Should Be Done?
  • Why do people support and defend illegal aliens entering the U.S.?
  • immigration to america,1890-1924?
  • Amend the Constitution?
  • Form I-130 help?
  • Friendship Canal to secure border from CA/Mexico border to TX/Mexico border?
  • i had an indian passport which had ECNR stamp. but my new passport does not have ECNR after name change etc..
  • what would happen if americans started jumping the fence to mexico?
  • If the North American Union is so good then why haven't they came right out and told the american ppl yet?