Illegal's in The United States;?
Do you believe in giving all illegal's in The United States Automatic Citizenship?
If yes:Why?
If No:Why?
Answer:
NO!! if we do this why don't we give all criminals a 'get out of jail free card'
No. Why should we give them anything?
people who broke our laws should not be rewarded.
Well. yes because if they are they pay taxes helping us out. No because then we will still have over population in many areas like Los Angeles. I have family there and it is fairly crowded to be honest.
Give 'em a jail term
NO!!
Legal immigrants should be given citizenship ahead of illegal aliens don't you think??
Illegal aliens should be deported and sent to the back of the line behind legal immigrants.
Can anyone give me a reason why illegal aliens deserve AUTOMATIC CITIZENSHIP AHEAD OF LEGAL IMMIGRANTS??
Warm cup of coffee, on their ride back
No. Why should we reward the criminals and punish law abiders? What incentive does any foreigner have to come legally if it's easier to get rights as an illegal immigrant!
Not automatic, they need to pass a complete backgroung history check from here and their country, and they need to pay back any and all benefits they took to show good faith,,and then we can see about citizenship.
ahhh get over yourselves and grow up!! i think you have nothing better to do and ask dumb questions
No, they committed a crime. If they wanted to become citizens then they should have come here legally like my grandmother and father did as well as my daughter's mom did.
No. Illegal would be the key word here.
There are enough problems with the legal immigrants and regular citizens.
When its someone illegal its just that much worse cause they are showing us that they dont obey the law.
No, this is one of the dumbest ideas that Ted Kennedy come up with the first time, and now that he trying to do it again, speaks for his mental need to be put out to pasture.
Nothing is more common than political "solutions" to immediate problems which create much bigger problems down the road. The current immigration bill in the Senate is a classic example.
The big talking point of those who want to legalize the illegal immigrants currently in the United States is to say that it is "unrealistic" to round up and deport 12 million people.
Back in 1986 Ted Kennedy said, it was "unrealistic" to round up and deport the 3 million illegal immigrants in the United States then. So they were given amnesty -- honestly labeled, back then -- which is precisely why there are now 12 million illegal immigrants.
As a result of the current amnesty bill -- not honestly labeled, this time -- will it be "unrealistic" to round up and deport 40 million or 50 million illegal immigrants in the future?
If the current immigration bill is as "realistic" as its advocates claim, why is it being rushed through the Senate faster than a local zoning ordinance could be passed?
We are, after all, talking about a major and irreversible change in the American population, the American culture, and the American political balance. Why is there no time to talk about it?
Are its advocates afraid that the voting public might discover what a fraud it is? The biggest fraud is denying that this is an amnesty bill.
Its advocates' argument is that illegal immigrants will have to meet certain requirements to become citizens. But amnesty is not about how you become a citizen.
The word is from the same root as "amnesia." It means you forget or overlook some crime, as if it never happened. All this elaborate talk about the steps illegal immigrants must go through to become citizens is a distraction from the crime they committed when they crossed the border illegally.
Instead, all attention is focused on what to do to accommodate those who committed this crime. It is a question that would be recognized as an insult to our intelligence on any other issue.
For example, there are undoubtedly thousands, perhaps millions, of unsolved crimes and uncaught criminals in this country and we cannot realistically expect to find and prosecute all these fugitives from justice.
But does anyone suggest that our focus should be on trying to normalize the lives of domestic fugitives from justice -- "bring them out of the shadows" in Ted Kennedy's phrase -- and develop some path by which they can be given an acceptable legal status?
Does anyone suggest that, if domestic criminals come forward, pay some fine, and apply to have their crimes overlooked, they can be put on a path to be restored to good standing in our society?
Just as we don't need to solve every crime and catch every criminal, in order to have deterrents to crime, neither do we have to ferret out and deport every one of the 12 million illegal aliens in this country in order to deter a flood of new illegal aliens.
All across this country, illegal aliens are being caught by the police for all sorts of violations of American laws, from traffic laws to laws against murder. Yet in many, if not most, places the police are under orders not to report these illegal aliens to the federal government.
Imprisoning known and apprehended lawbreakers for the crime of illegally entering this country, in addition to whatever other punishment they receive for other laws that they have broken -- and then sending them back where they came from after their sentences have been served -- would be something that would not be lost on others who are here illegally or who are thinking of coming here illegally.
Just as people can do many things better for themselves than the government can do those things for them, illegal aliens could begin deporting themselves if they found that their crime of coming here illegally was being punished as a serious crime, and that they themselves were no longer being treated as guests of the taxpayers when it comes to their medical care, the education of their children, and other welfare state benefits.
Incidentally, remember that 700-mile fence that Congress authorized last year? Only two miles have been built. That should tell us something about how seriously they are going to enforce other border security provisions in the current bill.
Absolutely NOT! By virtue of being here illegally in the first they have proven that they do not respect out laws nor our people. To the majority of Americans that is a slap in the face.
Some of the Mexican illegals believe that much of our southwest is rightfully theirs and are purposedly coming to our country as foreign invaders. They say that they will keep coming until they are a majority and can seize the land.
Anyone who believe that the immigration bill granting amnesty and automatic citizenship to these illegals is good for our country is a fool.
you can't do that.
plus i don't know where you are getting this from. no one will be given "Automatic Citizenship." you just want to stir up some lies. ignorant is what you are.
NO.
Our country has softened the Immigration situation by giving in back in the '80's. It was the amnesty bill. But after 20 years of the Amnesty, the illegal aliens are still ignoring our law, and continue to break our law. Not only by entering in illegally, but not paying taxes, carrying on other criminal activities, and draining our taxes by getting free schooling, and medical.
What ever happened to EARNING the Legal Residency Status, and then the Citizenship. By the way, the new bill in debate is misleading. The $5,000 fine, and the waiting period is only for citizenship. If an illegal alien only wants permanent residency, and NOT applying for the citizenship, then no fines, and no waiting period is being proposed.
What does this teach our kids? Go ahead and break the law, our Federal law, and it will be fine.
No. Why reward bad behavior?
No one is giving undocumented immigrants automatic citizenship.. where are you getting this information from? Read and education yourself first. The reform plan does not consitute an automatic legalization.
Just think on this: you have a business in a specific place where your neighbors are around 50,000 illegal immigrants and just few Americans. You open your business every day and every day the illegals are going to your place to buy something or to get your service. Now.. one day, you' re noticed "immigration" got your city and deport 49,500 illegals. Explain me how you'll pay your rent? how you will get money to survive with almost no customers?
Have anyone realize this? 12 millions of illegals are 12 millions of customers of all different business outside. Every person is a very important part of the economy of the Country and should be so hard to keep a lot of business without illegals.
Also, they are working with fake social security numbers making money for the owner of that number and at the end of the year they have no way to claim income tax return. Lets see..no way!! is a lot of money. Who want to loose that? probably the more racist person on this forum is getting a benefit of more than one illegal alien.
There is any smart person here who can understand what I said?
Absolutely not. These people are criminals. I would not be party to rewarding their criminal activity with citizenship any more than I would buy a steak dinner for someone who stole my car.
The Immigration information post by website user , MyTend.com not guarantee correctness.
More Immigration Questions and Answers ...