Cheap Labor?
>Isn't that what the whole immigration issue is about?
>
>Business doesn't want to pay a decent wage.
>
>Consumers don't want expensive produce.
>
>Government will tell you Americans don't want the jobs.
>
>But the bottom line is cheap labor. The phrase "cheap labor" is a myth,
>a farce, and a lie. there is no such thing as "cheap labor."
>
>Take, for example, an illegal alien with a wife and five children. He
>takes a job for $5.00 or $6.00/hour. At that wage, with six dependents,
>he pays no income tax, yet at the end of the year, if he files an
>Income Tax Return, he gets an "earned income credit" of up to $3,200
free.
>
>He qualifies for Section 8 housing and subsidized rent.
>
>He qualifies for food stamps.
>
>He qualifies for free (no deductible, no co-pay) health care.
>
>His children get free breakfasts and lunches at school.
>
>He requires bilingual teachers and books.
>
>He qualifies for relief from high energy bills.
>
Answer:
I say, just deport them all!
So, how do you really feel about it?
The Republicans want cheap labor.The Democrats want cheap votes.The American public wants a secure border.If they become legal citizens they will also be eligible for affirmative action.
You haven't a clue. You cannot file a Tax return to get any kind of tax credit without a ITIN number or a Social Security number. You cannot get a social security number unless you are legal to work. You can get an ITIN number, but those are only granted to temporary workers WITH the appropriate permits OR the non-citizen alien spouses of US Citizens who need an ITIN in order for the US Citizens taxes to be filed correctly.
To get "Section 8" housing, you need legal US status
To Qualify for food stamps, you cannot be illegal. Even my husband who is a legal permanent resident is not allowed to get food stamps.
Free healthcare? Give me a break. Even state sponsored programs for children typically cost some money. Most of them also require a Social Security number.
Many illegals do not send their children to school because you have to sign a child up for school with your drivers license or photo id that you also cannot get without a social security number. Many illegals teach their kids at home.
I personally blame every American who hires an illegal for the mess we are in.
As far as produce pickers if we used our inmates who are sitting in jail doing nothing but costing us money, maybe our jails wouldn't be as overpopulated as they are now and the farmers would save money and the price of produce would drop.
We need to stop giving welfare benefits to those who are here illegally it is ridiculous that we give them anything other than a bus ticket home.
I know a girl who's green card expired about 15 years ago and she couldn't find her social security card but when she recently went to the welfare office she was told not to worry about it they would push it through. If it were any other American citizen it wouldn't be done this way we would be @$%^ out of luck
JenniferinNy doesn't know what the heck she is talking about our schools are so overpopulated by the offspring of illegal aliens it isn't funny as far as a social security card see the story above and many illegals have stolen social security numbers. They are no longer hiding they are in your face protesting and sucking our system dry of any benefits they can get and they get more than you and I would.
You need to get a clue. I live in California and deal with them everyday and see first hand what is going on.
Pick up a random piece of fruit and tell me what country it's from. Higher produce prices. Right.
I agree...cheap labor is at the base for all this. Can't compete on the "global" market with 3rd world nations on 1st world wages. Everybody is working for a "better life" no matter where they are on the scale. Problem is..for many of us.that hope of "better" has been going away quickly. Education didn't pan out when they just turned around and outsourced the jobs or brought in cheap labor to take your place.
There is NOTHING free. Somebody is paying for it in one way or another. Even with things like section 8 housing and all..not all who need it and qualify, get it. They change the rules right and left to limit in other ways who gets it and who doesn't. Sometimes it's an endless spin downward with not much hope out...yet for others it's a free ride. There's just a dual set of laws and rules and standards. All I know is I pulled the short straw again.
But do you understand that they work just like you and half of our Americans take all that **** forgranted ok and most of them are well and can get a job but they file for SSI ok so before you start talking about immigrants look around you your people are doin it to there self they choose to hire cause they dont want to have to do it there self and they immigrants work all day picking **** ok so take a look around you at least there working and taking care of themselves half of americans can work but choose not to
Don't hold back now, just say what you mean. LOL! Hiring illegal immigrants may save the employer a few dollars and some paperwork but the real cost is measured in the ways which you have expressed. The real costs include ALL of the expenses which American citizens must fund from their own pockets. It is not fair for us to have to suffer this burden caused by persons in our country illegally. We need to immediately deport ALL ILLEGAL immigrants and require them to then return under legal circumstances IF their application for residency is approved. This is the only right thing to do. The truth is always easy and needs no debate.
Cheap labor is about the bottom of the list as to what the immigration issue is about. That can simply be corrected, if necessary, with a guest worker program. Personally I'm not convinced that it's necessary. The US appears to have plenty of people that appear to qualify.
The real issue is countries ability and right to control it's boarders and population. Population control is necessary to maintain an adequate standard of living. Unfortunately, this means that some people who wish to immigrate will not be allowed to. The best we can do is be as fair as possible as to who is allowed in. Violating the law by illegally coming into the country is unfair to those that pursue legal channels. Amnesty in any form should not be condoned as it encourages this illegal activity.
The attached video addresses the impact of immigration and population.
Most of illegal people getting those benefits is because they have U.S children. Even having U.S children they will not qualify for section-8 and about the taxes the majority of Illegal are paid the minimum wage, were they take a lot of taxes out which goes to those people working for the state, city and for those getting welfare which the majority are black people who are lazy and cant keep a job. And the bad thing is that those Illegal people cant claim they taxes back.
GET THE HECK OUT OF OUR COUNTRY!
The total cost of doing the wrong thing is never cheap.
Your Logic is flawless, I commend You.
Yes you are correct
first of all i can't believe some of the response i'm reading, because when you look into american history, it's all about people immigrating somehow, those 12 million didn't get here over night, but people didn't complain much when the economy was ok, immigrants are just a scapegoat for the governments failure, search for answers and vote for the right candidate next time
Slow down i know how your feeling i had id thieft. We must keep up the pressure on the Gov.Close the borders & enforce our laws. By the way great Input.Thanks
The Immigration information post by website user , MyTend.com not guarantee correctness.
More Immigration Questions and Answers ...