Does any one agree?

all of the illegal ppl comeing from mexaco shuld have to join the us army for 4 years b4 they can be givin there rights to live here...and they would have to know ENGLISH!!!!

does anyone agree?

Answer:
a little too Roman empireish to me
Great Idea. I wish it were that way.
not a bad idea except I wouldnt want someone who does not love our country enough to die for it guarding my back
It's a good idea, yet the do-gooders in this world wouldn't stand for conscription.
I do think that could be one way they could earn citizenship, but it would not fix the problem.
the first thing we need to do is stop the illegals from coming in. Until we do that the rest doesn't really matter
Perhaps if they go then your illiterate body won't have to go. Is that what you're saying?

Bottom line, slavery was abolished in the 1860s and I don't know about you, but I wouldn't want these people in the Army defending me.
A lot of the people that are coming over the border in droves are not fit to serve. Many are too old or too young, many are sick, and many are not physically fit.

I agree that military service could be a good route to citizenship, provided that the potential recruit doesn't break our laws to get to the recruiting station.
yeah but they are still coming over the border,,,,,it solves nothing
I think you should look into learning how to spell in English first, before you criticize anyone else and their educational status.

PEOPLE
COMING
MEXICO
SHOULD
BEFORE
GIVEN

Damn, dude!
Why would we want foreign nationals in our army?

I say we arrest them and instead of deporting them right away, we put them in prison labor camps so that we can get a good supply of cheap labor, and then we deport them after a couple of years.
I agree! But not just anyone coming illegally from Mexico... anyone coming illegally from ANYWHERE!
I think they should at least know basic English before coming. But I think all the criminals in jail for life should be sent to the US army and should be the first ones to be sent to war.
As soon as you can communicate with proper English, you can tell others to learn the language.

I see four obvious grammatical errors and one archaic syntactical error in your post.
none would come..
I'm sorry, no, I only want people that have a vested interests and allegiance to the USA protecting this nation.I want to know where their loyalties lie before they are handed a weapon.Illegal aliens from any country ,should not be forced to serve in the armed forces.They shouldn't even be here to begin with.
Many legal Mexican Americans have served bravely and with high honors in our military.
No I think the lines of communication would do more harm than good. It would be very dangerous to have several languages all going at the same time.
Volunteered citizens make great a great army, if there is anything more polar opposite to that than enforced illegal immigrants, I don't know what it could be.
I agree they should speak English. When my family came (legally) from Germany and Italy, they learned English.
I don't agree with the army thing. A lot of them are malnourished and not physically strong enough to get into the army. And I don't think America means to them what it does to those of us born and raised here.
no, when you force people into the armed forces, you are not going to have a good army. sorry, but I also dont think that just because you want to come and work that you want to kill people for that country. so no, i dont think that anyone will agree with you.

The immigration information post by website user , MyTend.com not guarantee correctness

  • Can someone plz explain to me why people want open borders ?
  • Are mexicans.?
  • What do I do, if I am a US citizen who got married in the US, but want to move to Canada?
  • Does anyone know of any US citizens who have gotten Chinese citizenship?
  • what is the country in europe and north america less strict and the easiest in immigration laws?
  • Cultural pride: mexico gives police slingshots, what does that say?
  • how much money do i have to prepare, so i can go to US or Australia?
  • Does a Canadian Citizen need a Student Visa to study in the US??
  • Is anybody here an immigrant?
  • How come illegal aliens get US benefits/loans easier than US citizens in need of assistance?