Consider and Comment on Another Immigration Case Scenario?

A Mexican woman meets and marries her US citizen husband in her own country. The couple lives there for a few years. They have a rocky marriage, but she loves him and tries to make it work. After a few years, he decides they should come to the US. He smuggles her across the border. He is a very jealous man. Her life in the US is hell. He locks her in their apartment during the day. They live in a hot, humid climate and she is not allowed to turn on the air conditioning when he's not home. He beats her, rapes her and humiliates her.

She is an "illegal." Do you think she should be allowed to stay, or do you think she should be deported?

Answer:
what part of ILLegal can you not understand

that said his actions toward another human being should be treated the same as if she were a citizen

he should have a court hearing and let justice prevail

she should be deported asap when the trial is over
It sounds like Deportation would be a God Send for the poor woman. What you have described has happened to many American women in Iran. I'd imagine they'd love to be deported too but can't take their children with them so they stay.
I don't like "if" questions.IF my aunt had balls she'd be my uncle.
Sounds like deporting her would be doing her a favor. They should also deport the husband for being such an a-hole.
sounds like she should be happy.
I agree with Wsox.
No
if we controlled the borders instead of allowing gangs.. drug dealers, criminals, terrorist cross at will. this would not have been an issue at all
but no matter what this jerk would have went after someone... he needs jail time with someone big ghay guy named bubba.. and everyone look the other way for a few years..


http://www.mybordersolution.com/...
I have a three-year-old daughter who was born mentally and physically handicapped. She will require a great deal of special care for her entire life. I'm 45, and have been working and paying into Social Security since I was 16. When I mentioned on this site that the funds that I contributed and she has a genuine right to are being depleted by noncitizens, you can guess what happened. I was met with derision, disdain, and outright hatred from pro-illegal regulars on this site. That was my turning point. My heart has hardened somewhat toward the plight of illegals. Sympathy runs both ways.
She should be held as a material wittiness until the trial is over and then deported.

In addition to the charges related to the abuse of his wife the husband should be charged with gross stupidity. Getting his wife a spouse visa would have been simple. There was no need to smuggle her into the country.

The medicine information post by website user , MyTend.com not guarantee correctness.

  • According to US Immigration laws priority is always given to the wealthy and talented !! but ...?
  • Have you ever seen a Polish girl that wasn,t wearing jeans?
  • Could we give the illegals amnesty if.?
  • What are my chances of getting hired at a company if I move to Australia from the US?
  • We need to end ILLEAGEL immagration and we need to end it now!?
  • Is it fair that green cards be handed out like potato chips. just a thought(read on)?
  • What do I do about an illegal alien that is illegally employed?
  • Do I have to update my childs passport if they have changed to look at?
  • Is the U.S.A. becoming a communist country...???
  • Mexicans only need visa for america...?