Should the immigration debate be left to indigenous people like Lou Dobbs?
Answer:
Gabe, what do you think of this holocaust deniers?
Do they also deny that the US stole half of Mexico?
Truth is Whites invaded America and conducted the most terrible genocide, a most heinous holocaust, against the Indigenous population. A nation born in crime has no right to impose its criminal laws on a hard working people, the most direct descendants of the inhabitants of this land. The Mexica have travelled up and down the Rio Grande for millenia. You have no right to stop them. You CAN"T stop them.
What you can do is act rationally a welcome your fellow men. The people impoverishing the US are not Hispanic, they are CEOs and senators. So stop taking it out on us.
After the US invaded half of S.America i can hardly see any moral ground for the US to stand on. Let's be fair, you are all immigrants and children of immigrants. When you arrived there were huge campaigns to throw you out. Prohibition was a direct attack on the German and Irish.
I know most of you want to forget history, but your victims will never let you. Abandon you holocaust denial and accept that we have a RIGHT to go anywhere we please.
10
Blessed are they who are persecuted for the sake of righteousness, 9 for theirs is the kingdom of heaven.
Mathew 5
think of how much better off they'd have been with a better immigration policy. It's called learning from mistakes
It wasn't a country. It was Land.
Indians didn't have any Laws.
You also forgot to mention that we gave 'small pox' to the Indians to.
Sorry but I am only 3rd generation.
My great-grandparents came from Sicily in the 1900's.
And yes, they did it Legally.
The Native Americans didn't have an idea of ownership of land in their society. In many cases the land was actually bought from them with trinkets and firewater. They thought they were taking advantage of the settlers. I think your question is very sad. Everyone in this country should be having a debate on immigration. It's called the first amendment to the Constitution.
unlike the current immigrants ,we brought civilization to a backwards people. Todays immigrants just want to be parasites on this civilization. Thats why europe has an immigration problem too, but not south america or africa.
sorry if it sounds racist, but that is the truth.
If the Native Americans really wanted to win, they would have fought harder.
We won't make the same mistakes.
Help stop illegal immigration.
www.numbersusa.org
We have the right to be a sovereign nation and protect our borders regaurdless of how we got here. You nor I were alive and had nothing to do with what happened to the Indians. With that said I think Lou Dobbs doesnt help this issue. He is extreme and exaggerates to try to get his point accross. Im afraid there is no easy answer to this one. You cant round up illegals and ship them out. Its also not fair to the immigrants who came here legally that the illegals should just be granted citizenship. I know a majority are just looking for a better way of life. They are not taking jobs from Americans because most of the people claiming that they are will not do the jobs these people are doing. To answer your question though I think Lou Dobbs needs to shut his mouth until he can be completely honest about the issue.
You are misguided and your question is irrelevant.
Since when did logic and reasoning have anything to do with politics in America?
The native americans should have "fought harder"?
This is the argument of an idiot.
European justification of the destruction of native civilizations because they were "savages" or "not christian" seems to be with us still with people like Dobbs.
Most peoples attitude seems to be, "now that I'm here, shut the door".
why you people keep look back in the past
in order to justify your illegal actions?
YOU ARE CRIMINALS CAUSE YOU REFUSE
TO FOLLOW OUR IMMIGRATION LAW period.
solution? jail time and then deportation
good luck to you and you have a nice trip...
lou dobbs is wonderfull.
i dont agree with everything he says. but he is at least on the right track.
i hope he runs in 08' i'ed vote for him.
but for now i'll vote for tom tancredo.
Illegal aliens have no rights. you are making an argument comparing apples to oranges. Europeans didn't "Invade" an established country. even Native Americans had no sense of "Unity" outside their tribes. they warred with each other, usually over the very land we bought from them. Illegal Aliens are coming into a country, governed by laws, and expect to have rights the minute they step their illegal asses onto our soil. sorry, doens't work that way. go through the proper channels, apply for US Citizenship, quit sponging off our (WAY TOO) generous gevernment programs. Then they could be considered eligible for the debate, as they could express their voice with their right to vote.
SOmeone above mentioned the 1st amendment. again, its a right that belongs to US Citizens...Become a citizen, not an illegal, and end this whole silly issue. its not tough.
All U.S. citizens who were born in our country are indigenous people or native Americans, and that describes about 85% of our citizens. I gave up raping and pillaging years ago when I retired as a pirate. My ancestors were conquerers, and I am damned proud of them. It is white Europeans who made this country great.
We would be better off leaving the solution to our country's immigration crisis to patriots like Lou Dobbs on CNN at 6:00 EDT (I never miss it), than leaving it up to traitors like Kennedy/Bush/McCain and you! We need to vote for a conservative president who will stop the illegal alien invasion of our country; the only reliable candidates are below.
I WONDER WHAT THE INDIANS THINK ABOUT ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION.
has anyone actually talked to them about it or are you all gonna play the "Indian" card. lol.
don't speak for the Indians unless you are one ok.
and i don't mean 1/8 Indian either.
why do people keep trying to play the history game. well such and such years ago this happened...
and your point being what?
its 2007 and we have big issues to deal with. sooo get your head out of your behinds. the population has much increased since the 1800's. i think we need to realize this.
What are you talking about , do you even know or understand what you just said ?
Are you a illegal that doesn't even belong in this country ?
You differently don't know American history and are living in the past .
As for Lou Dobs , he seems to be one of the few Americans speaking the truth and must be putting some pressure on you or you wouldn't be attacking him .
yes,
The medicine information post by website user , MyTend.com not guarantee correctness.